When The Heart Rate Formula Isn't On Target
Cara's Fitness Blog
POSTED: 10:12 pm EDT April 11,
2005
Cara Kempf is a certified personal trainer with the Fitness Zone in Carmel and a group fitness instructor with NIFS in downtown Indianapolis. She can be contacted at fitnessblog@theindychannel.com.
"I am trying to lose around 10 pounds by adjusting my diet and walking. I am a little confused about the target heart rate. I am 41 years of age. After using the formula, I come up with 125. If I maintain my rate at 125, I do not feel that I am really working out at all. I usually walk between 35 to 45 minutes four to five times weekly. I do a little weight training and some yoga as well. Any advice would be helpful." -- Kelly
Thanks for writing, Kelly -- this is a very common question. First off, you have to remember that the formula is just an estimate of where your heart rate should be when you exercise. The problem with any and all formulas is that they don't take into account added factors, like what shape you might be in. I have seen 70-year-old women out pounding the pavement in the morning, and I would guess their heart rate is not the "normal" target heart rate for sedentary or semi-active women their age -- the one you would get with the formula.Although the formula is great for giving you something to start with, I don't feel you should follow it as absolute truth, especially if you don't feel like you're exercising intensely enough. Use it simply as a guide, and then try the talk-test, or rate of perceived exertion (RPE). If you can carry on a full conversation while exercising, you probably aren't working intensely. If you can sing, you definitely aren't working intensely. You should be able to speak here and there throughout your workout, but it should be somewhat difficult to hold a complete conversation.Then, on a scale of one to 10 -- 10 being the absolute hardest you could work out -- rate the difficulty of the exercise you are doing right then. If you want a mega-calorie-burning workout, you want to stay around seven or eight. (Although you can still burn calories at a lighter pace, it just takes longer!)Sounds to me like you are on the right track to dropping those 10 pounds! Remember, one to two pounds per week is healthy weight-loss, and a healthy diet will be the deciding factor in the last three to five. Keep up the good work!
"I am trying to lose around 10 pounds by adjusting my diet and walking. I am a little confused about the target heart rate. I am 41 years of age. After using the formula, I come up with 125. If I maintain my rate at 125, I do not feel that I am really working out at all. I usually walk between 35 to 45 minutes four to five times weekly. I do a little weight training and some yoga as well. Any advice would be helpful." -- Kelly Previous Stories:
- April 5, 2005: Fun In The Sun
- March 21, 2005: Cardio And Weights
- March 14, 2005: The Sea Of Advice
- March 7, 2005: Antidote For The Blues
- February 28, 2005: Childhood Obesity? Parents Hold The Key
- February 21, 2005: Organizing Weight Training
- February 7, 2005: Workouts In The Water
- January 31, 2005: Eating Out? Stay Healthy!
- January 24, 2005: Re-Prioritize To Stay Healthy
- January 18, 2005: You Can Do It!
- January 10, 2005: Fat-Burning Foods
- January 3, 2005: Preparing For 2005
- Cara's 2004 Fitness Blogs
Copyright 2005 by TheIndyChannel.com All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.






