TheIndyChannel.com

Hurricane Katrina

Spacer

Related To Story
Joe Raedle/Getty Images
Federal health officials are urging that hurricane victims be moved out of FEMA-supplied trailers as quickly as possible because of a health threat.
HURRICANE KATRINA

Hurricane Katrina: What Did The Government Do?

Government Response Criticized In Wake Of Disaster

POSTED: 12:07 pm EDT August 10, 2009
UPDATED: 2:03 pm EDT August 17, 2009

The wide extent of the damage caused by Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans stretched beyond ruined homes and stranded families: The local, state and the federal government all took a beating to their image in the field of emergency preparedness.

According to the National Response Plan, disaster prevention and response planning are first and foremost a responsibility of the local government of the affected area. Once local resources run out, the burden climbs the bureaucratic ladder, going from county to state until it reaches the federal government.

In light of this responsibility, many were outraged to find after the storm hit that, according to a Congressional report, the Louisiana government had been aware of the inadequacy of its emergency response system for decades.

The report, called Hurricane Katrina: A Nation Still Unprepared, states that "when it received warnings of Katrina's approach, the state had reason to know that its emergency response systems were likely to fail ... and fail they did." On the federal level, former Federal Emergency Management Agency director Michael Brown admitted that he knew the weekend before Katrina made landfall that neither his agency nor the federal government were prepared to deal with the effects of the storm.

The deluge of criticism of the local, state and federal government focused largely on long-term mismanagement of FEMA and the lack of leadership in the aftermath of the storm. While housing tens of thousands of refugees would be no easy task for any city, temporary housing was clearly underprepared and poorly managed.

The major example is the relief site set up at the Louisiana Superdome. Designed to serve 800, the site was overwhelmed by more than 30,000 people and became no more than an endless waiting room. Some saw the insufficient aid as a mark of racial discrimination, and singer Kanye West caused a stir when he announced on national television that "George Bush doesn't care about black people."

A poll conducted by ABC news on September 2, 2005, showed that citizens were pointing the finger at a variety of groups and individuals. About 44 percent said they blamed President George W. Bush for the chaos that ensued the storm, and 75 percent agreed that the local and state governments were inadequately prepared.

Not all news was bad. Before the storm began, FEMA attempted to stave off catastrophe by preemptively deploying supplies and even refrigerated mortuary trucks to the area. After the storm, FEMA provided housing relief and paid hotel bills for over 700,000 displaced people. Many requested FEMA trailers for temporary housing, and while some were sent, the supply was far below the demand.

The United States Coast Guard is on the short list of government entities that was actually praised for its emergency response. The Coast Guard rescued over 35,000 refugees stranded in a flooded New Orleans.

As the crisis began to resolve in the following year, the federal government resolved to improve national preparedness primarily through improving communication between departments and agencies at the local, state and federal levels.
The following are comments from our users. Opinions expressed are neither created nor endorsed by TheIndyChannel.com. By posting a comment you agree to accept our Terms of Use. Comments are moderated by the community. To report an offensive or otherwise inappropriate comment, click the "Flag" link that appears beneath that comment. Comments that are flagged by a set number of users will be automatically removed.


Video

President Barack Obama helps New Orleans mark the five year anniversary of Katrina, where he made a promise to the city's residents. More


Former New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin says he should have ordered a mandatory evacuation for Hurricane Katrina sooner than he did. More


Actor Brad Pitt speaks with CNN on his efforts to help rebuild New Orleans in the wake of Hurricane Katrina. More


New Orleans is deluged with heavy rainfall
as Hurricane Katrina storms into the city. More


As Hurricane Katrina hammered New Orleans, the city's levy system failed -- which made for a human catastrophe.More


When then levees broke, there was only one way out for hundreds of homeowners -- through the roof. More


The Superdome provides shelter for Katrina victims. It was also ground zero for those livid with the sluggish federal response to the storm. More


Five years after Katrina, New Orleans' defenses against another hurricane are stronger than ever. But are they strong enough? More


Five years after Hurricane Katrina, CNN's Tom Foreman explains how the so-called "shelter of last resort" has been rebuilt. More


Five years after Katrina, CNN's Tom Foreman explains how New Orleans residents are rebuilding and restoring their ruined neighborhoods. More