Who is Monserrate Shirley? The answer depends on who you ask.
Before Nov. 10, 2012, few of her neighbors had met Shirley. Those who did knew a skilled ICU nurse who had primary custody of her daughter Brook following an acrimonious divorce. Some of her neighbors knew her ex-husband, John Shirley, who'd formerly lived with her in the Richmond Hill neighborhood.
Few, if any, had met her new boyfriend, Mark Ray Leonard.
Just after 11 p.m. on Nov. 10, 2012, Shirley's home at 8349 Fieldfare Way exploded. The blast collapsed the homes immediately to the north and south of Shirley's home – trapping the Olvey family and killing Dion and Jennifer Longworth.
At first, neighbors thought they would be searching for Shirley's body. When they found out she'd been out of town at the time, they counted her among themselves: a victim.
Only a few months later – after a tearful TV interview in which Shirley declared her innocence and then begged for privacy, and then a second, equally tearful announcement of her indictment on arson and murder charges – neighbors' opinions of her had changed.
In a plea agreement reached between Shirley and Marion County Prosecutors in January 2015, Shirley signed a statement of facts corroborating many important parts of the State's case against Mark Leonard and his brother Robert Leonard – notably that they'd attempted to burn the house down before.
Shirley said they'd agreed upon a plan in October 2012 to light a fire by blocking the chimney of the home and altering the thermostat. Shirley and Leonard made plans to be out of the house that night, and found accommodations for her daughter and cat – but the plan failed.
The next weekend, Shirley said, they tried again. Shirley and Leonard went to a casino. Brook and the cat stayed elsewhere. And, again, the plan failed.
It was on Nov. 4, 2012, according to Shirley, that the Leonard brothers hatched the plan to fill her home with gas and light that on fire.
On Nov. 10, 2012, Shirley and Leonard again went to a casino. Brook stayed at an alleged accomplice's house. The cat, Snowball, was boarded. And shortly after 11 p.m., investigators say a timer on the microwave reached zero – causing a metal cylinder inside to explode and starting a chain reaction that would damage more than 100 homes and claim two lives.
From accomplice to key witness
For more than two years, Shirley maintained her innocence.
In January 2013, Shirley agreed to give up her nursing license during the investigation. One day later, the Indiana State Board of Nursing voted unanimously to suspend it.
Shirley admitted to the conspiracy, and agreed to testify at the trials of Mark and Bob Leonard, as well as other, then-unnamed defendants, in exchange for the State dropping its pursuit of the life without parole sentence.
Information apparently provided as part of the agreement also led to the arrest of the fourth and fifth suspects in the case: Gary Thompson and Glen Hultz.
Their efforts were stymied, however, by decisions made by Judge John Marnocha to prevent cross-examination of witnesses about Shirley's demeanor on the night of the explosion, as well as neighbors' opinions of her plea agreement.
Jurors did hear from Shirley's ex-husband, John Shirley, about their divorce and her subsequent changes after meeting Mark Leonard – but they did not get to hear about an alleged affair in which she blackmailed a doctor for "hush money."
Leonard's defense attorneys argued unsuccessfully that testimony about the affair was necessary for them to properly counter the State's case against their client.
"Part of the state's presentation of this case is that she has no will of her own, can't manipulate a situation, and it clearly shows that she can manipulate a situation for financial gain," lead defense attorney Diane Black argued.
Marnocha was unswayed, however, saying it didn't matter "whether she's had one affair or 10 affairs or 100 affairs."