INDIANAPOLIS - Convenience stores in Indiana are keeping up their fight to be able to sell cold beer, as a trade group said Tuesday it was appealing a judge's decision upholding the state law that prohibits them from selling the beverages chilled.
The Indiana Petroleum Marketers and Convenience Store Association announced it was asking a federal appeals court to review the district court judge's ruling last month rejecting its challenge. Federal Judge Richard Young ruled that the state has legitimately drawn a line by allowing only liquor stores to sell cold beer.
Scot Imus, the convenience store association's executive director, said the group maintains that the state law goes against common sense.
"It is clear the monopoly liquor stores have limits consumer choice and hurts the growth of our state's economy," Imus said. "Indiana has the dubious distinction of being the only state that regulates beer sales based on temperature."
The association is also challenging the restrictions with a lawsuit in a Marion County court.
The Indiana attorney general's office has defended the state law, saying the proper place to fight the restrictions was the Legislature, not the courts.
Efforts by opponents of the restrictions, however, have been unsuccessful in attempts over the past several years to persuade legislators to allow cold beer sales in convenience stores and groceries.
Young wrote in his ruling that expanding the sale of cold beer beyond liquor stores, taverns and restaurants would make Indiana's alcoholic beverage laws tougher to enforce by creating many more outlets where minors could buy cold beer.
The Indiana Association of Beverage Retailers supports the current law, saying that grocery and convenience stores don't face the same the age restrictions as liquor stores on who can enter and the requirement to hire clerks with state liquor licenses.
An appeal of the judge's ruling was expected because the convenience store association has spent a large sum of money to sue the state, said Patrick Tamm, CEO of the liquor store group.
Tamm released the following statement:
We are not surprised by the notice to appeal. The plaintiffs have spent a considerable sum of money to bring this challenge and pursue litigation against the state of Indiana. No doubt they will spend a considerably larger sum to pursue any appeals after a definitive ruling by Judge Young. These plaintiffs are large corporate interests with deep pockets and have much to gain in overturning Indiana law – even as they admitted in their own testimony calling their gas stations and convenience stores that sell alcohol "profit centers."
Crash kills Ind. teen pilot seeking world record
The plane of an Indiana father-son team attempting to fly around the world has crashed after taking off from American Samoa.
Watchdog details what's right, wrong about DCS
The Indiana Department of Child Services handles cases appropriately most of the time, but "there's always room for change," said a leader…
Lake Co. judge strikes down Ind. right-to-work
A Lake County judge struck down Indiana's right-to-work ban on certain union fees in a second legal blow to the contentious law passed in 2012.
Two dogs found together on streets inseparable
People all over the world are hoping they can adopt a pair of dogs that were found wandering the streets together almost two weeks ago in…
Firearm permits rising in Indiana
Indianapolis residents alone hold nearly 10 percent of the state's conceal-carry permits. With the growing number of people with guns, there…
Judge sets bond for man accused of murdering mom
A judge set a bond Wednesday in the case of a man accused of murdering his mother with a hammer.