INDIANAPOLIS - A federal judge has taken Indiana Gov. Mike Pence to task, saying Pence told the court he had no power to enforce Indiana's gay marriage ban and then ordered executive agencies to do so following court rulings.
Judge Richard Young ruled Tuesday that Indiana must recognize same-sex marriages performed in other states , but put the order on hold as a federal appeals court is taking up his earlier decisions on the issue.
Young says Pence issued contradictory memoranda after Young struck down the ban in June, at first ordering agencies to abide by the ruling but later telling them to uphold the ban after an appeals court stayed Young's ruling.
As a result, the judge named Pence as a defendant in the lawsuit.
Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis political science professor William Blake said legally it won't make a difference to either side, but politically, he thinks it could be positive.
"I think this may be beneficial to the governor -- if there are some that thought he didn't do enough during the legislative session to push HJR-3, it now makes him look more committed to the cause," Blake said.
The RTV6 political insiders had a different take.
"I think the judge reprimanded him pretty harshly -- I've never seen it before where a sitting governor has been spanked by a judge," former state democratic chairman Kip Tew said.
"Perhaps the governor's office should've done a few things differently when they issued out their legal opinion, especially in dealing with same-sex marriages from out of state," Editor-in-Chief of indypolitics.org Abdul-Hakim Shabazz said. "I don't think it's a Democrat or Republican issue, I think it's the judge basically not being happy with the Pence folks saying, 'hey, you told me one thing, then you did something else.'"
Pence’s communication director released a statement Wednesday:
"By law a governor exercises authority over the executive branch of government. Governor Pence has a duty to uphold the laws of the state and will continue to do so while respecting the courts' rulings. That does not make the governor a proper party in every lawsuit against the State of Indiana."
The judge’s ruling is on hold until a federal appeals court rules on the merits of this case or another one dealing with the issue of same-sex marriage in Indiana.
The 7th Circuit Court is scheduled to hear oral arguments next Tuesday.
Hoosiers, Indy Snow Force prep for wintry roads
Indy Snow Force went to work Saturday night preparing the city for a possible heavy blanketing of snow Sunday.
StormTeam 6 Alert: Wintry mix to fall overnight
It's a StormTeam 6 Alert Day as Hoosiers brace for widespread weekend snow.
Suspect arrested in shooting death of Indy teen
Indianapolis police said Saturday they had arrested a suspect in the fatal shooting of a 13-year-old boy.
IACC offers 'Deflate-Gate' dog adoption deal
Indianapolis Animal Care and Control had a little fun with the Deflate-Gate controversy on Super Bowl weekend – offering discounted dog…
Two teens drown in pool at apartment complex
SOUTH BEND, Ind. (AP) -- South Bend police say two people drowned in a pool at an apartment complex after the 19-year-old man started to…
Ty Pennington to appear at Indy Home Show
"Extreme Makeover Home Edition" TV host Ty Pennington was scheduled to make an appearance at the Indianapolis Home Show Saturday.