Related To Story |
Experts: Indiana Shouldn't Dictate Immigration Law
Lawmakers Discuss Issue At Hearing Tuesday
POSTED: 9:23 am EDT September 10, 2008
UPDATED: 9:42 am EDT September 10, 2008
INDIANAPOLIS -- Indiana lawmakers reopened the debate over illegal immigration Tuesday, even after experts testified that the state didn't have much ground to stand on.Tuesday's hearing was expected to be heated, after the issue of a state immigration law was left unresolved last session, 6News' Norman Cox reported.Most of the witnesses called on Tuesday were lawyers, many of whom questioned the state's ability to even pass an immigration law, since they argued that it is a federal responsibility.
"You can possibly push the limits of your authority under constitutional law and hope for the best," said Indiana University law professor John Scanlan.There are cases proceeding through the federal court system that could give states more authority over immigration, but lawyers warned that until the U.S. Supreme Court rules on them, Indiana could get in trouble by proceeding on its own."It is not permissible, not is it prudent, for a state to take federal law into its hands. That's essentially what pre-emption is all about. It's not allowed, and if you do it, you're going to get burned at the very basic level of the pocketbook," said Valparaiso law professor Bernard Trujillo.The committee also heard from a group that did a demographic study of Indiana, estimating that there are about 100,000 illegal immigrants in Indiana.The committee will have four more hearings on the matter.
Previous Stories:
- March 10, 2008: Businesses Trying To Kill Immigration Plan, Lawmaker Says
- February 21, 2008: Dems Block Changes To Immigrant Bill; Republicans Walk
- February 21, 2008: Major Changes Made To Illegal-Immigrant Bill
- February 12, 2008: Stepped-Up Enforcement, Proposed Law Target Illegal Immigrants
- January 27, 2008: Illegal Immigrant Proposal Stirs Strong Emotion
- January 23, 2008: Bill That Would Punish Illegal-Alien Hiring Advances
- May 1, 2007: Thousands March In Indy For Immigration Reform
- May 6, 2006: Hoosiers Hold Rally Against Illegal Immigration
- May 1, 2006: 'Day Without Immigrants' Impacts Indiana Businesses, Schools
Copyright 2009 by TheIndyChannel.com All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.




