NewsCall 6 Investigates

Actions

Indiana's discipline disparity takes on new meaning amid racial inequality protests

Posted at 7:12 PM, Jun 05, 2020
and last updated 2020-06-05 19:12:08-04

INDIANAPOLIS — As many people focus their concern about racial injustice at police officers, Call 6 Investigates has uncovered disparities impacting black people often start in school.

Call 6 Investigates Kara Kenney spent months digging through federal and state data and found all black students in Indiana are more likely to be disciplined and arrested than students of other races.

Black students in Indiana are nearly four times as likely to get an out-of-school suspension than their white peers, according to state data, and twice as likely to receive an in-school suspension than white students.

Indiana also ranks 4th highest in the country when it comes to the rate of out-of-school suspensions for black teens in middle and high school, according to the Center for Civil Rights Remedies at UCLA.

24% or nearly a quarter of black middle and high school students in Indiana have been suspended at least once.

Nicole Kenney’s teenage son, William, got a 10-day suspension after William and his brother say they stood up to a bully.

"When I got suspended for two weeks I was like, dang, I'm not going to be in school and I'm going to be missing out on a lot of work," William said. “When we get in trouble, it’s a bigger consequence.”

William said the bully, who is white, got a three-day suspension.

Experts said the state’s discipline disparity has lifelong impacts on black people in Indiana.

This School-to-Prison Pipeline in Indiana study shows students who get in trouble in school are more likely to get arrested by police and go to jail or prison.

The Positive School Discipline Institute is working to stop that cycle.

PREVIOUS | Schools get training on different approach to student discipline

"We're trying to get to the relationship between the educator and the student so we can keep kids engaged in school and on the right track and reduce suspensions, because we know when they're put outside of the school community we know they are at much greater risk for encountering law enforcement," JauNae Hanger, with the Children’s Policy and Law Initiative of Indiana and the Positive School Discipline Institute, said.

The discipline disparity is happening with student arrests as well.

State data shows black students make up 12% of the state’s student population, yet comprise 26% of arrests on school property.

Experts say it’s not because black students are exhibiting more criminal behavior.

The Positive School Discipline Institute trains school leaders, teachers, school police and other staff about cultural differences, the role of trauma in a children’s behavior, and implicit bias — which are the unconscious views we have about certain groups of people.

“It's more than implicit bias. It's unconscious racism," Gwen Kelley, with the Children’s Policy and Law Initiative of Indiana and the Positive School Discipline Institute, said. “How do we deescalate situations? It doesn't happen without training because your automatic instinct is to say I'm not going to tolerate that on my watch."

"If you don't know how to deescalate with a child, much like if you don't know how to deescalate with an adult, you're going to have conflict,” Hanger said.

Schools are not required to do implicit bias training, and some school leaders feel it’s a huge time commitment for their staff.

"Yes we think it should be required," Kelley said.

Call 6 Investigates checked with the Indiana State Department of Education to see what the agency is doing with regards to training.

The Comprehensive Positive School Discipline Guide was released includes implicit bias and restorative practices. IDOE is also partnering with the state’s Division of Mental Health and Addiction to provide Peace Learning Center trainings regionally at no cost to the schools.

“This fall starts with the southern region and then we will bring on the other two regions,” Adam Baker, IDOE spokesperson, said. “We should have 30 school districts trained in positive school discipline, including implicit bias.”

As people continue to march in Central Indiana against racial injustice, experts say they’re working to stop tense police interactions long before they happen.

"We need all these players to come together and change the policies and practices systemically in their school,” Hanger said. “That's a big ask. But that's what we're asking our law enforcement to do."

With an unprecedented amount of attention on racial injustice, they’re hoping to see more attention on the topic in schools.

“When you start talking about race, people think well you’re calling me a racist — no,” Kelley said. “We’re talking about issues that are real. It takes courage to talk about racism.”

PREVIOUS | Black students disciplined at higher rates in Indiana schools

“We know what the solutions are, we just have to be brave enough to say that it’s important enough for us to do it,” Hanger said.

YOUR SCHOOL’S DISCIPLINE DATA

  • Enter your district’s name and click on disciplinary report on the right-hand side of the page.
  • Note: this data collection is from the 2015-2016 school year.
  • The next data collection, from the 2017-2018 school year, won’t be released until 2020

Questions You Can Ask Your Own School

  • What is the school’s discipline policy?
  • What is the process when a student is disciplined or arrested? Will parents be notified?
  • What training is being given to police and resource officers who are interacting with students?
  • Does the school use seclusion rooms or restraint on students?
  • Does the school have school resource officers?
  • Is there a use of force policy for school resource officers?
  • Is there record-keeping and reporting about the activities and outcomes of policing interactions at the school?
  • More questions for parents can be found here.

How to Search Discipline Data for Your School

FEDERAL DISCIPLINE DATA- SEARCH BY SCHOOL:
https://ocrdata.ed.gov/DistrictSchoolSearch

STATE OF INDIANA DISCIPLINE DATA- SEARCH BY SCHOOL:
https://inview.doe.in.gov/