NewsCall 6 Investigates

Actions

School district re-tests for radon after Call 6 finds results with high levels

Posted: 5:00 PM, Jan 14, 2019
Updated: 2019-01-14 23:55:30-05
BartholomewConsolidated.JPG

COLUMBUS — A school district has re-tested its buildings for radon following questions from Call 6 Investigates about test results with high levels of the cancer-causing gas in several buildings.

Radon is an odorless, tasteless carcinogen and is the number one cause of lung cancer among non-smokers.

Call 6 Investigates analyzed data from the Indiana State Department of Health and found test results from 2013 that showed high levels of radon in Bartholomew Consolidated School Corporation classrooms.

PREVIOUS | Most schools ignore federal radon testing recommendations

The EPA recommends schools take action to fix the problem when the radon levels hit 4.0 pCi/L or above.

Call 6 Investigates found the following 2013 results at schools in Bartholomew Consolidated (in pCi/L):

  • W D Richards Elementary School 13.4
  • L F Smith Elementary 11.0
  • Lillian Schmitt Elementary School 7.9
  • Southside Elementary School 7.5
  • Parkside Elementary School 7.1
  • CSA Lincoln Campus 5.0
  • Northside Middle School 4.1

We brought those results to Superintendent Dr. Jim Roberts who, at a September school board meeting, vowed to look into what happened in 2013.

Roberts did not become superintendent in Bartholomew Consolidated schools until 2016.

In October, Call 6 Investigates reported it was unclear whether the school district took action upon learning of the high radon test results.

PREVIOUS | Most schools ignore federal radon testing recommendations

In his first sit-down interview, Roberts updated Call 6 Investigates Kara Kenney about the situation.

“Radon is now on our radar,” Roberts said.

SUPERINTENDENT EXPLAINS THE 2013 RADON TEST

Roberts explained in 2013, the district tested 21 buildings and 10 buildings came back with a reading of 4.0 pCi/L or higher.

The testing company, Alliance Environmental, did the 2013 test during fall break.

Radon experts told RTV6 that testing when students are out of the building is a no-no because the air handlers aren’t running normally and can give you false positives.

“Testing should always be done under occupied conditions,” Kyle Hoylman, founder and managing partner of radon testing company Protect Environmental, said.

PREVIOUS | State launches program to test day cares for radon gas

Alliance Environmental has ignored repeated questions from Call 6 Investigates as to why they performed the district’s radon test over fall break when the buildings were unoccupied.

Roberts said at the time, the school staff did not want to disrupt students with a radon test, and that’s likely why the test was done over fall break. Roberts said he believed the 2013 test did not accurately portray the actual radon levels at the time.

CALL 6: You do not believe students or teachers were exposed to high levels of radon?

ROBERTS: I do not, no. Based on the timing of the test in 2013, and how quickly the school corporation got after the various buildings. Helping with air flow, exhaust, and ventilation. I do not believe so.

Between 2014 and 2018, Bartholomew Consolidated spent thousands of dollars to improve air quality, heating and air conditioning and ventilation at nine different buildings.

Dr. Roberts said the decision to do so was not directly related to the radon test.

"Those decisions were based on aging buildings who had a variety of concerns whether it was needing to add space, renovate space, or take care of the inner workings, the efficiency — those units like HVAC that need to be addressed," Roberts said.

The district paid Alliance Environmental about $13,500 in 2013 for a radon test, records show.

DISTRICT RE-TESTS FOR RADON FOLLOWING CALL 6 STORY

After Call 6 Investigates raised questions about radon, Bartholomew Consolidated schools paid Alliance Environmental an additional $8,500 to come back and re-test for the cancer-causing gas.

The new test was performed while the students were in session, from October 16-18, 2018.

This time, the results were much different.

All student buildings tested below 4.0 pCi/L.

CALL 6: When you got those results, what was your reaction?

ROBERTS: It was relief. For the safety of our kids and our staff members, we are relieved we are looking at numbers under 4.0 pCi/L and we don’t want to spend extra money if we don’t have to. That money can be spent on student learning instead of spent on mitigating radon.

Two buildings without students did show slightly elevated levels of radon — the Information Services Center and the BCSC Administration Building.

CALL 6: You work in this building. Are you concerned at all?

ROBERTS: I’m not.

In the administration building, a storage area and lending library showed the higher radon results — not where workers spend much time.

The district plans to re-test both buildings and come up with a plan for the future.

Roberts said he’s communicated information about radon at public meetings and social media.

CALL 6: Did you hear from parents?

ROBERTS: We did not. I still think it’s something that not a lot of us are well educated about. Many of us have not even tested our own houses.

LEGISLATION FILED COULD REQUIRE TESTING IN SCHOOLS

Because of Call 6 Investigates’ reporting, state lawmakers filed legislation that would require schools to test for radon.

Currently, Indiana schools are not required by law to test for the cancer-causing gas.

READ MORE | State lawmakers file two bills to boost radon testing in schools

Our investigation found 96 percent of school districts in Indiana haven’t tested for radon in the last decade, despite EPA recommendations to test at least once every five years.

Bartholomew Consolidated schools plan to keep testing in the future, whether it’s required by law or not.

“We want to develop a schedule of re-testing across our system in terms of radon,” Roberts said. “How we’ll do that, how often we will do that — that’s being worked out in terms of cost and efficiency. We would like to be a leader on anything that benefits our kids.”

Many school districts are looking into how to pay for radon testing.

You can get home tests for free at the health department, but testing schools can cost thousands of dollars.

Roberts said they’re looking at whether they can train and certify their own staff to do the testing.

“There’s a litany of things we try to be concerned with, and this is now one of them,” Roberts said. “Radon is now on our radar. We view ourselves as the district of choice in Indiana and hopefully others will view us that way as well.

MORE TOP STORIES| Noblesville police respond to unsafe sledding call | Lafayette police release body cam footage from incident where officer shot by fellow officer | Man who led police on chase that ended on interstate took his own life | Indiana issuing February food stamps early | IMPD search for man who threw bag from car with injured puppy inside

Top Trending Videos