NewsCall 6 Investigates


Township trustee avoids prison time after pleading guilty to stealing from taxpayers

Phyllis Shafer admitted to theft
Posted at 4:21 PM, Dec 20, 2018
and last updated 2018-12-20 22:13:33-05

HENRY COUNTY — A township official will avoid prison time after pleading guilty to stealing taxpayer funds.

On Dec. 12, Liberty Township Trustee Phyllis Shafer was sentenced to 2.5 years with six months home detention, followed by two years of probation.

As part of a plea agreement, Shafer pleaded guilty to five felony counts of theft and prosecutors dismissed the remaining charges, including official misconduct.

Shafer must pay $1,365 in restitution to the Liberty Township Trustee Board, $2,707 to the State Board of Accounts and $11,207 to Cincinnati Life, the township’s bonding company.

Records show Shafer is still serving as the township trustee, but her term expires on Dec. 31.

When Call 6 Investigates called the township office Thursday, a woman answered and said Shafer was unavailable.

Shafer is accused of stealing more than $9,000 from the taxpayers in the eastern Henry County community of 1,455 people.

When a public official is convicted of crimes involving their work in public office, they can be forced to forfeit the elected position.

A recent SBOA audit found Shafer paid herself excess salaries in 2013, 2014, 2015.

READ MORE | Liberty Township trustee arrested on theft, official misconduct charges

She and the township clerk, John Shafer, also received reimbursements for supplies and services without the proper documentation including computer ink, stamps, tree removal, and cemetery repair.

“No evidence was provided to support the validity of these payments,” according to the audit.

Current law allows for township officials to be married to each other, such as a township trustee and township clerk.

The township also racked up $1,365.34 in penalties and interest from the Internal Revenue Service because claims and taxes were not submitted on time.

The audit also pointed out that the trustee served as the township executive and the township fiscal officer, and was responsible for all aspects of the township’s financial activity.

“As a result, there was no oversight of Township financial activity on an ongoing basis by another individual,” read the audit. “Due to this lack of segregation of duties, fraudulent payments and improper recordkeeping were able to occur and not be identified timely.”

State auditors spent so much time looking for records, they racked up additional investigation costs.

The audit covered Jan.1, 2013 and Dec.31, 2015.

Phyllis Shafer has been in office since at least Jan.1, 2011, records show.

Phyllis Shafer did return $1,360 by personal check on March 19, 2015, records show.

When questioned by state auditors, Shafer said that she was “messed up.”

When contacted by Call 6 Investigates in 2016, Phyllis Shafer asked if the audit would be on the news, but did not provide any further comment.

MORE TOP STORIES  | Trucking companies looking to put drivers behind the wheel | Teen suspect dead after | 'Grinch' driver caught on cam plowing through | Richmond middle school shooting suspect's mom called police

Top Trending Videos